I'm not sure what to make of this and without the full paper it is always hard to know what it really says. However, from the abstract they seem to be claiming that a protocol that avoids failure achieves maximum recruitment of motor units. What is interesting is that muscle fibre recruitment was higher towards the end of the 15 rep set - which was going to failure - than the heavy 3 rep max set. This is the size principle at work! The thing about failure though is that you know that you are there. Stopping 3 reps short of failure is one thing...but unless you fail how do you know when you were 3 reps away from failure?! Fail and then you are certain you were there. UPDATE James Steele has now analysed this paper and offers some very insightful comments on his blog: To Failure or Not to Failure - That is the Question.... Doug McGuff's comments are also very helpful on the Body by Science blog Muscl...
.......interesting things about fitness, strength, diet and performance.